Home of the Kit Pellow Fan Association

Collecting Cleveland Baseball Since 1982

Collecting Cleveland Indians Topps team sets from 1952-present, as well as post-war minor and major league autographs.

From the Collection: Alex White, sp, Cleveland Guardians

Alex White
Alex White

From the Collection: Alex White, sp, Cleveland Guardians

Trading for prospects is always risky. Trading with Colorado for pitchers is also risky. Be careful with both.

Alex White was a very talented pitcher for the University of North Carolina when he was taken with the #15 overall pick of the 2009 draft by Cleveland. By 2011, he was Cleveland’s top pitching prospect and profiled as a solid #2 or #3 starter with the ceiling of an ace.

White made the majors in 2011, but in his third start, he injured his hand. While recovering, Cleveland included him in a package of prospects, including Cleveland’s #2 pitching prospect Drew Pomeranz, for Colorado’s ace Ubaldo Jiménez.

Was it a good trade? I don’t know. Ubaldo Jiménez was terrible for Cleveland for the remainder of 2011 (77 ERA+) and 2012 (72 ERA+ and led the league in losses). But he was very good in 2013 (115 ERA+) and helped the team to the playoffs. That was also his walk year, so…funny how that works.

Alex White would never find success in the majors and last pitched in the majors in 2012.

It was another player included in that trade, Drew Pomeranz, who actually panned out. He was an All-Star in 2016, won 17 games in 2017. And he is still out there, at 36 years old, pitching well for the Chicago Cubs.